We have to admit: AI’s pretty cool for businesses. From automating things that would likely take us days, like creating listings. It can also make competitor analysis faster and crosslist to multiple platforms in a breeze.
Lately, sellers have reported another kind of scams plaguing them in several marketplaces: the AI photo scam. Buyers demand return and/or refund of items, with an obviously AI-generated photo as proof. Some even receive photos of items they didn’t sell!
This is a headache for sellers across platforms. Here’s how these scams usually operate, what different marketplace requirements for opening disputes, and how you can avoid being scammed in the future.
How AI Photo Scams Work
The premise is simple: A buyer files a dispute using a photo of the item with flaws like stains, damaged hardware, or fake tags. They claim the item not as described (INAD). While not all disputes result in returns and refunds, consistent bad reviews stemming from these disputes can affect your store ratings.
It’s also reassuring to know that most reseller platforms have strict policies with regards to submission of proof for INAD items. This means they don’t automatically side with the buyer when mediating a dispute. However, this is not true of all platforms.
What Do AI-Edited Photo of Damaged Items Look Like?
These characteristics are often seen on photos edited with AI to look broken or damaged:
- Lighting inconsistencies show shadows when there should not be any;
- A filtered look on the image;
- Damages that look unnatural on the material (like a rip on the fabric but with suspiciously smooth edges;
- Logos and letters seem warped; and
- Missing metadata (though image compressing can cause this)
Some photos may be edited by software like Adobe Photoshop instead of being fed to AI, but inconsistencies can still be seen especially when compared to actual photos of the item.
Marketplace Requirements for Photo Proof

Mercari requires buyers to photograph all items received when filing for a dispute. They may also ask buyers to provide photos of the shipping label and external packaging.
Poshmark asks for similar evidence; the seller can also see what photos the buyer sent and inspect them for AI manipulation. Etsy follows a similar process.
Depop requires buyers to submit photo proof for an INAD claim. Photos must clearly show the issue for Depop can assess the claim. However, you won’t see the photos the buyer sends unless you specifically ask support to see them (which you must). In this case, you will only see the issue, reason, and damage as described by the buyer.
What Can You Do as a Seller During Disputes?
The common ways to resolve disputes across platforms is either to agree to return, issue a partial or complete refund (with sometimes letting the buyer keep the item), or report a return issue after the item has been returned. Note that responding to these disputes involves specific deadlines depending on the platform.
When confronted with buyers using AI photos as proof of an INAD claim, here’s what you can do:
Platform | What You Can Do | Additional Steps |
|---|---|---|
All platforms |
| |
Poshmark |
|
|
Etsy |
|
|
Mercari |
|
|
Depop |
|
|
Protecting yourself from future AI photo scams

As scammers learn to exploit AI features and try to cheat the system, sellers also need to take proactive steps to protect themselves during disputes. The most important thing you can do is to use clear, detailed listing photos. These photos are your starting point when comparing photos sent by the buyer.
Next, diligently take packing photos, and if possible, packing videos. This step will strengthen your claim that the items had no damage or flaws beyond those described in the listing.
Some sellers request photos and a handwritten note with the buyer’s name and date, like this seller from Threads. This may be enough to deter those who are planning to open a dispute with an edited photo.
While asking for an unboxing video seems sensible, we don’t recommend it, as it may involve you contacting the buyer outside the platform. This could violate platform policies and result in account restrictions or suspensions. Also, not all platforms support videos for disputes: Mercari is one of them.
The Final Verdict
As scamming schemes become more elaborate, sellers have to stay alert to how these scams operate. Resellers are often at risk since they sell items in different conditions, and scammers could exploit existing flaws to make the items appear worse than it is using edited photos.
Understanding reselling platform policies is also key to fighting against these scams and successfully using your photo evidence in disputes. Stay ahead by keeping up-to-date with marketplace policies.